|
On Aug. 31, 2006, just four days after Comair
Flight 5191 crashed in Lexington, Federal Aviation
Administration Spokeswoman Laura Brown, responding to Associated
Press reporter Jeffrey McMurray’s questions about the role that
controller fatigue may have played in the accident, tried to
assure the public that controllers would not be forced to report
to their facility if they did not feel rested enough to work,
saying, “If they don't believe they're fit for duty, they're
supposed to tell us that. You won't be penalized for not
reporting for work."
But just three days later, on Labor Day weekend,
the FAA unilaterally imposed work rules on controllers. One of
those rules took away the ability of controllers to use their
accrued sick leave if they felt they were not rested enough to
work their assigned shift. It’s outlined in Article 25 of the
FAA’s imposed work rules, under Section 3: “Sick leave cannot be
granted for rest or minor inconveniences.” Aside from being a
punitive measure against controllers as the FAA set aside fair
collective bargaining procedures to impose its will, the
rest/fatigue issue is a serious safety concern, as identified
last week by the National Transportation Safety Board and is
more evidence of a worsening staffing crisis as the FAA forces
controllers to work tired against their will.
Attached is an audio clip
from a Sept. 6, 2006
briefing for FAA managers and supervisors in St. Louis on how to
implement the work rules on controllers. The speaker is Tom Cassady, the FAA’s manager of field labor relations and customer
service group. He works directly under the agency’s chief labor
relations official, Joe Miniace.
In this clip, Cassady is boasting about reversing
the 2-2-1 (two late-day shifts, two early-day shifts, one
midnight shift) schedule for the sole purpose of shortening the
time off between work weeks. When he is questioned as to the
rationale behind such a scheduling practice he responds by
stating “they can’t call in sick when they're tired.”
The transcript_:
CASSADY: Look at your 2-2-1 and reverse it. Start
with a mid. Come back on a day. Come back on an evening and see
how much time off in between shifts you get.
(audience question – unintelligible, but NATCA
assumes it had something to do with the fact that controllers
won't like the reverse 2-2-1)
CASSADY: They don’t like being tired and not
being able to call in sick either.
Unidentified Female Voice: You end up with not
having, uhm, I think you end up with having 32 hours off between
your Friday and your Monday. That's the downside to that when we
looked at it.
CASSADY: OK
(audience question - unintelligible)
CASSADY: So the thought provoking was look at
different ways, not just your standard 2-2-1, because it is an
issue right now. They can’t call in sick when they’re tired.
-Doug Church
Director of Communications
National Air Traffic Controllers Association
301-346-8245 (cell)
202-220-9802 (office) |